Vote Outcomes Plenary - Fifth Senedd 15/07/2020
Cynnwys
Contents
Rheoliadau Cynllunio Gwlad a Thref (Ffioedd am Geisiadau, Ceisiadau Tybiedig ac Ymweliadau Safle) (Cymru) (Diwygio) 2020
The Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications and Site Visits) (Wales) (Amendment) Regulations 2020
| O blaid / For: 40 | Yn erbyn / Against: 1 | Ymatal / Abstain: 12 |
|---|---|---|
| Alun Davies MS | Michelle Brown MS | Nick Ramsay MS |
| Delyth Jewell MS | Russell George MS | |
| Lynne Neagle MS | Janet Finch-Saunders MS | |
| Hannah Blythyn MS | Suzy Davies MS | |
| Jane Hutt MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| Adam Price MS | Neil McEvoy MS | |
| Dai Lloyd MS | Angela Burns MS | |
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | Paul Davies MS | |
| Jenny Rathbone MS | Darren Millar MS | |
| Vaughan Gething MS | David Melding MS | |
| Jack Sargeant MS | Mark Isherwood MS | |
| Julie Morgan MS | Gareth Bennett MS | |
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| David J. Rowlands MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Mandy Jones MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
Cyfnod 4 Bil Anifeiliaid Gwyllt a Syrcasau (Cymru)
Stage 4 Wild Animals and Circuses (Wales) Bill
| O blaid / For: 53 | Yn erbyn / Against: 0 | Ymatal / Abstain: 0 |
|---|---|---|
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| David J. Rowlands MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Nick Ramsay MS | ||
| Neil Hamilton MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Mandy Jones MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Gareth Bennett MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
Gwelliant 1 Sian Gwenllian - Dadl Llywodraeth Cymru - Cyflwyno terfynau cyflymder 20mya yng Nghymru
Amendment 1 Sian Gwenllian - Welsh Government debate: Introducing 20mph Speed Limits in Wales
| O blaid / For: 44 | Yn erbyn / Against: 5 | Ymatal / Abstain: 4 |
|---|---|---|
| Jenny Rathbone MS | Gareth Bennett MS | David J. Rowlands MS |
| Sian Gwenllian MS | Michelle Brown MS | Mark Isherwood MS |
| Lynne Neagle MS | Darren Millar MS | Mandy Jones MS |
| Vaughan Gething MS | Neil Hamilton MS | Suzy Davies MS |
| Jack Sargeant MS | Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | |
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Nick Ramsay MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
Cynnig - Dadl Llywodraeth Cymru: Cyflwyno terfynau cyflymder 20mya yng Nghymru
Motion - Welsh Government Debate: Introducing 20mph Speed Limits in Wales
| O blaid / For: 45 | Yn erbyn / Against: 6 | Ymatal / Abstain: 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Nick Ramsay MS | Neil Hamilton MS | Suzy Davies MS |
| Leanne Wood MS | Gareth Bennett MS | Mark Isherwood MS |
| Hannah Blythyn MS | David J. Rowlands MS | |
| Delyth Jewell MS | Darren Millar MS | |
| Angela Burns MS | Michelle Brown MS | |
| Kirsty Williams MS | Mandy Jones MS | |
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
Cynnig i ddiwygio Rheol Sefydlog 18.10: Swyddogaethau Pwyllgor yn Ymwneud â Goruchwylio Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru
Motion to amend Standing Order 18.10: Committee Functions Relating to the Oversight of the Wales Audit Office
| O blaid / For: 51 | Yn erbyn / Against: 2 | Ymatal / Abstain: 0 |
|---|---|---|
| Vikki Howells MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| Nick Ramsay MS | Gareth Bennett MS | |
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| David J. Rowlands MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Mandy Jones MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
Cynnig i ddiwygio Rheolau Sefydlog: Y Comisiwn Etholiadol a Phwyllgor y Llywydd
Motion to amend Standing Orders: The Electoral Commission and the Llywydd's Committee
| O blaid / For: 51 | Yn erbyn / Against: 2 | Ymatal / Abstain: 0 |
|---|---|---|
| Adam Price MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| Julie Morgan MS | Gareth Bennett MS | |
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| David J. Rowlands MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Nick Ramsay MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Mandy Jones MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol - Cynnig heb ei ddiwygio
Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales - Motion without Amendment
| O blaid / For: 9 | Yn erbyn / Against: 43 | Ymatal / Abstain: 1 |
|---|---|---|
| Bethan Sayed MS | Vaughan Gething MS | Michelle Brown MS |
| Neil McEvoy MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| Leanne Wood MS | Julie Morgan MS | |
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | David J. Rowlands MS | |
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | |
| Delyth Jewell MS | Jenny Rathbone MS | |
| Adam Price MS | Nick Ramsay MS | |
| Sian Gwenllian MS | Lee Waters MS | |
| Dai Lloyd MS | Lynne Neagle MS | |
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Gareth Bennett MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Mandy Jones MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
Gwelliant 1 Darren Millar - Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 1 Darren Millar - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 13 | Yn erbyn / Against: 40 | Ymatal / Abstain: 0 |
|---|---|---|
| David J. Rowlands MS | Julie Morgan MS | |
| Nick Ramsay MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| Angela Burns MS | Vikki Howells MS | |
| Paul Davies MS | Lee Waters MS | |
| Mark Isherwood MS | Mick Antoniw MS | |
| David Melding MS | Alun Davies MS | |
| Russell George MS | Kirsty Williams MS | |
| Darren Millar MS | Dai Lloyd MS | |
| Suzy Davies MS | Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | |
| Mandy Jones MS | Hannah Blythyn MS | |
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | Vaughan Gething MS | |
| Laura Anne Jones MS | Adam Price MS | |
| Michelle Brown MS | Huw Irranca-Davies MS | |
| Hefin David MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Gareth Bennett MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
Gwelliant 2 Neil Hamilton - Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 2 Neil Hamilton - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 2 | Yn erbyn / Against: 49 | Ymatal / Abstain: 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Gareth Bennett MS | Nick Ramsay MS | David J. Rowlands MS |
| Neil Hamilton MS | John Griffiths MS | Mandy Jones MS |
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
Gwelliant 3 Gareth Bennett - Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 3 Gareth Bennett - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 2 | Yn erbyn / Against: 49 | Ymatal / Abstain: 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Neil Hamilton MS | Angela Burns MS | David J. Rowlands MS |
| Gareth Bennett MS | Vikki Howells MS | Mandy Jones MS |
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Nick Ramsay MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
Gwelliant 4 Rebecca Evans - Dadl Plaid Cymru Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 4 Rebecca Evans - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 29 | Yn erbyn / Against: 24 | Ymatal / Abstain: 0 |
|---|---|---|
| Hannah Blythyn MS | Sian Gwenllian MS | |
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | Neil McEvoy MS | |
| Jane Hutt MS | Dai Lloyd MS | |
| Jack Sargeant MS | Gareth Bennett MS | |
| Mike Hedges MS | Mark Isherwood MS | |
| Julie Morgan MS | David J. Rowlands MS | |
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| John Griffiths MS | Janet Finch-Saunders MS | |
| Vaughan Gething MS | Angela Burns MS | |
| Rebecca Evans MS | Nick Ramsay MS | |
| Jayne Bryant MS | Bethan Sayed MS | |
| Mick Antoniw MS | Adam Price MS | |
| Lee Waters MS | Paul Davies MS | |
| Kirsty Williams MS | Russell George MS | |
| Lesley Griffiths MS | Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | |
| Dawn Bowden MS | Delyth Jewell MS | |
| Carwyn Jones MS | Darren Millar MS | |
| Ken Skates MS | Laura Anne Jones MS | |
| David Rees MS | Michelle Brown MS | |
| Alun Davies MS | David Melding MS | |
| Lynne Neagle MS | Mandy Jones MS | |
| Jenny Rathbone MS | Leanne Wood MS | |
| Rhianon Passmore MS | Llyr Gruffydd MS | |
| Julie James MS | Suzy Davies MS | |
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
Gwelliant 5 Neil Hamilton - Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 5 Neil Hamilton - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 2 | Yn erbyn / Against: 49 | Ymatal / Abstain: 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Neil Hamilton MS | Vaughan Gething MS | Mandy Jones MS |
| Gareth Bennett MS | Laura Anne Jones MS | David J. Rowlands MS |
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Nick Ramsay MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
Gwelliant 6 Neil Hamilton - Dadl Plaid Cymru Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 6 Neil Hamilton - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 2 | Yn erbyn / Against: 49 | Ymatal / Abstain: 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Neil Hamilton MS | Joyce Watson MS | David J. Rowlands MS |
| Gareth Bennett MS | Jayne Bryant MS | Mandy Jones MS |
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Neil McEvoy MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Nick Ramsay MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
Gwelliant 7 Neil McEvoy - Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 7 Neil McEvoy - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 9 | Yn erbyn / Against: 42 | Ymatal / Abstain: 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Dai Lloyd MS | Joyce Watson MS | David J. Rowlands MS |
| Bethan Sayed MS | Mark Drakeford MS | Mandy Jones MS |
| Neil McEvoy MS | Jayne Bryant MS | |
| Sian Gwenllian MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | Lynne Neagle MS | |
| Adam Price MS | Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | |
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | Vaughan Gething MS | |
| Delyth Jewell MS | Nick Ramsay MS | |
| Leanne Wood MS | Ken Skates MS | |
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Gareth Bennett MS | ||
| Kirsty Williams MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
Gwelliant 8 Neil McEvoy - Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol
Amendment 8 Neil McEvoy - Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales
| O blaid / For: 1 | Yn erbyn / Against: 50 | Ymatal / Abstain: 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Neil McEvoy MS | Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | David J. Rowlands MS |
| Kirsty Williams MS | Mandy Jones MS | |
| Neil Hamilton MS | ||
| Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | ||
| Julie Morgan MS | ||
| Nick Ramsay MS | ||
| Dai Lloyd MS | ||
| Vaughan Gething MS | ||
| Hannah Blythyn MS | ||
| Mick Antoniw MS | ||
| Laura Anne Jones MS | ||
| Ken Skates MS | ||
| Gareth Bennett MS | ||
| Lesley Griffiths MS | ||
| Michelle Brown MS | ||
| Lynne Neagle MS | ||
| Angela Burns MS | ||
| Sian Gwenllian MS | ||
| Bethan Sayed MS | ||
| Mark Drakeford MS | ||
| Rhianon Passmore MS | ||
| Llyr Gruffydd MS | ||
| John Griffiths MS | ||
| Leanne Wood MS | ||
| Jayne Bryant MS | ||
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | ||
| Jane Hutt MS | ||
| Jeremy Miles MS | ||
| Jack Sargeant MS | ||
| Dawn Bowden MS | ||
| Darren Millar MS | ||
| Alun Davies MS | ||
| David Rees MS | ||
| Hefin David MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Mark Isherwood MS | ||
| David Melding MS | ||
| Russell George MS | ||
| Suzy Davies MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Adam Price MS | ||
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Delyth Jewell MS | ||
| Vikki Howells MS | ||
| Janet Finch-Saunders MS | ||
| Joyce Watson MS | ||
| Paul Davies MS | ||
| Julie James MS | ||
Dadl Plaid Cymru - Cymru Annibynnol - Cynnig wedi'i ddiwygio
Plaid Cymru debate - An Independent Wales - Motion as amended
| O blaid / For: 29 | Yn erbyn / Against: 24 | Ymatal / Abstain: 0 |
|---|---|---|
| Mick Antoniw MS | Neil Hamilton MS | |
| Vikki Howells MS | Nick Ramsay MS | |
| Kirsty Williams MS | Sian Gwenllian MS | |
| Lesley Griffiths MS | David J. Rowlands MS | |
| Huw Irranca-Davies MS | Dai Lloyd MS | |
| Yr Arglwydd / Lord Elis-Thomas MS | Bethan Sayed MS | |
| Mark Drakeford MS | Laura Anne Jones MS | |
| Hefin David MS | Neil McEvoy MS | |
| Rhianon Passmore MS | Angela Burns MS | |
| Jeremy Miles MS | Mandy Jones MS | |
| Hannah Blythyn MS | Russell George MS | |
| Julie Morgan MS | Rhun ap Iorwerth MS | |
| Vaughan Gething MS | David Melding MS | |
| Jane Hutt MS | Darren Millar MS | |
| Joyce Watson MS | Delyth Jewell MS | |
| John Griffiths MS | Mark Isherwood MS | |
| Jayne Bryant MS | Janet Finch-Saunders MS | |
| David Rees MS | Gareth Bennett MS | |
| Julie James MS | Michelle Brown MS | |
| Dawn Bowden MS | Paul Davies MS | |
| Lynne Neagle MS | Suzy Davies MS | |
| Jack Sargeant MS | Leanne Wood MS | |
| Ken Skates MS | Adam Price MS | |
| Alun Davies MS | Llyr Gruffydd MS | |
| Mike Hedges MS | ||
| Lee Waters MS | ||
| Rebecca Evans MS | ||
| Jenny Rathbone MS | ||
| Carwyn Jones MS | ||